Cremesheen Lipstick - Modesty

MAC

Cremesheen Lipstick - Modesty

53 positive 0 neutral 16 negative

Based on 69 Reddit mentions

$33.94

Buy on Amazon

We may earn a small commission.

Most discussed features

Sentiment summary across the product areas Reddit users mention most.

Reddit mentions

Original Reddit posts and comments behind this analysis.

Filtered by featuresatisfactionClear feature

In Honor of one of Today's Beauty Steals: What's Your Fav Macximal Lipstick Shade?

I love their lipsticks. These are the ones in my collection. I love them all it’s so hard for me to choose one. I’m a light-medium olive if that helps. Amorous, Yash, Blankety, Creme d’nude, cream in your coffee, chili, modesty, syrup, thanks it’s Mac!, pink peppermint, velvet teddy, stone, see shee

...

ooqpoo in r/Ulta

September 6, 2025 11:17 PM

14

Tips for choosing the perfect, every day lipstick?

You're so welcome! Lipsticks and glosses are my favorite makeup, & MAC my holy grail. Must own 20 at least. 😂 Some potential colors, although I am light but warm so lavender is not great on me. But check out pink peppermint, Mehr, Syrup, Angel & modesty is my absolute favorite. However, you may find

...

Bippy73 in r/Sephora

March 8, 2026 1:29 AM

5

what are your favourite cool toned products?

I have so many recs! I’m quite fair and neutral leaning cool toned, but it feels like I’m actually allergic to most warm toned products hahah Here are my favourite cool toned products: Blush: Ilia blush stick (at last), ilia baked blush (sensation), mac play go blush (totally synced), haus labs blus

...

igunix in r/PaleMUA

May 23, 2026 12:15 AM

4

Mac Lipstick Haul With Swatches

This is my kind of haul! I have over a hundred MAC lipsticks, they’ve been my favorite for like 28 years lol Blankety, Modesty, and Alone Time are some current faves, great choices! Crème In Your Coffee and Paramount are fantastic fall shades.

BabyYodasMacaron in r/Ulta

July 30, 2025 12:33 AM

4

Issue with lip products.

Human skin tone is relative. Technically my skin appears to be some tone of light orange. My lips are pinky peach. I am extremely cool toned. Almost every lipstick turns orange on me. I have to wear purple based products. But if you put me next to a standard color wheel, I would be in the peachy sid

...

NewMoonDweller in r/coloranalysis

June 4, 2026 4:37 PM

2

Deinfluence my cart/help me pick my first Mac lipsticks!

You’re welcome! Here is the swatch, and I gave my best to swatch them in order of mentioning 😁 https://imgur.com/a/HTYqiJU Top row: Alone Time, Hug Me, Blankety, Modesty, Creme in Your Coffee Bottom row: Viva Planet, Honeylove, Velvet Teddy, Cool Teddy, Dubbonet, Thanks it’s MAC Hope this helps! P.s

...

fireplacegoddess3297 in r/OliveMUA

May 29, 2026 7:40 AM

2

Lip shade color theory and mlbb shades.

As soon as I read “gray pink” my mind immediately went to MACs “Modesty”. It’s definitely that vibe for me and one of my more loved lipsticks of my collection. Others to check out: “Thanks! It’s MAC!” - by MAC, of course. lol. I see a lot of velvet teddy mentioned here. Interestingly, it swatches or

...

BougieBurlap in r/Fairolives

July 15, 2025 12:15 AM

2

MAC Lippies for pickup for today’s sale 😍😍😍

I can’t believe i walked away from this after realizing I don’t actually need any. I grabbed some ouai curl cream. I had just picked some up at Mac’s 40% off sale (last month?) national lipstick 💄 day… LOVE MODESTY

KaleidoscopeDry3608 in r/Ulta

September 7, 2025 1:58 PM

2

Autumnal lip combos

Stone, stone, stone! (MAC liner) It looks SO good on us, even straight men have been complimenting my lip makeup since I've started wearing it. 😅 Modesty and Acting Natural lipsticks are my favorite pairings, they give such a moody autumn vibe (they're shockingly 'toasty' brown if there was a cool o

...

holdthebutterplease_ in r/Fairolives

September 25, 2025 8:55 AM

2

Help! Struggling to find the perfect neutral nude lipstick

Most of the shades ypu mentioned are more pinkish than nude in my opinion. My nudes: mac stone, greige, smalltalk, dervish, subculture; lipsticks: creme d nude, creme cup, flashpot, myth, modesty, thanks it’s mac, honeylove.

mandarina111 in r/PaleMUA

February 7, 2026 3:21 PM

1

Top alternatives in Lipstick

#1