Cremesheen Lipstick - Modesty

MAC

Cremesheen Lipstick - Modesty

64 positive 3 neutral 18 negative

Based on 85 Reddit mentions

$32.36

Buy on Amazon

We may earn a small commission.

Most discussed features

Sentiment summary across the product areas Reddit users mention most.

Reddit mentions

Original Reddit posts and comments behind this analysis.

High-end makeup that actually worth the investment.

My favorite MAC lipsticks: Powder Kiss- Be My Bridesmaid, Girls Weekend, Taken Matte- Viva Planet, Honeylove, Acting Natural (usually to mute other colors, which it’s fantastic for!), Soar, Whirl, Viva Empowered Satin- Pink Peppermint, Blankety, Modesty Lustreglass (mind you these are being reformul

...

BabyYodasMacaron in r/Sephora

August 1, 2026 11:47 PM

16

Mauve: what it is and isn’t

Mauve is my favorite color. But it has a spectrum from light to dark and brighter to muted, as well as warmer mauve (browner) and cooler mauve (grayer). A couple of those on the second slide are mauve (the sweat suit and the top left button shirt). One of my favorites is MAC Soar lipstick, the curre

...

BabyYodasMacaron in r/OliveMUA

January 25, 2026 12:58 AM

29

If Nars Vainilla is your perfect shade what are good lipsticks for your skin color?

Is there a common problem with the colours you are trying? Vanilla is a good shade match for me and I need quite desaturated lipsticks. To give an example, Mac Syrup is like my brightest one ha. I really like N14 from YSL, Blazd Donut from Fenty and Macaron lip oil from Haus Labs. And Alone Time and

...

CAPTAINR0GERS in r/PaleMUA

December 8, 2025 6:03 PM

16

Soft pink lip recommendations for lip combo to go with Mac lipliner in stone or greige?

So the thing about Stone is that when you're a muted fair olive, it's not going to resemble anything like it does on her or most of what you're going to find on Google. See how green it looks against her skin? If you're olive, it won't look green on you. That's our starting point. When you put cool

...

holdthebutterplease_ in r/Fairolives

September 12, 2025 7:56 PM

14

In Honor of one of Today's Beauty Steals: What's Your Fav Macximal Lipstick Shade?

I love their lipsticks. These are the ones in my collection. I love them all it’s so hard for me to choose one. I’m a light-medium olive if that helps. Amorous, Yash, Blankety, Creme d’nude, cream in your coffee, chili, modesty, syrup, thanks it’s Mac!, pink peppermint, velvet teddy, stone, see shee

...

ooqpoo in r/Ulta

September 6, 2025 11:17 PM

14

For the cool toned girlies

I saw this on Instagram the other day and laughed. I love cooler toned lipsticks and MAC has my favorite formula that doesn't irritate my lips but I do not own any of these lol. Syrup, mehr, modesty, be my bridesmaid, girls weekend, and faux all look nice on me!

UptownEgg in r/Sephora

March 5, 2026 3:00 AM

7

Lipsticks that look like the marketing images for Pillow Talk?

Rituel de Fille's Hex marketing images look super cool/lilac but videos reveal it is also warmer than the marketing and might be a good match for the Pillow Talk image. But they use beeswax. Possibly KIKO Gossamer 140 'Light Mauve' but it isn't totally clear if the product is vegan. MAC Modesty appe

...

AntTown in r/VeganBeauty

October 17, 2025 9:43 PM

12

I had no business buying more lipstick but here is my mini haul. What did you guys get for the 40 percent off sale?

I can’t get enough of Mac to the point where im going to end up with every (current) shade 😆 I bought Gel, O, Del Rio and Modesty. I’m still debating on picking up Film Noir and I missed out on Alone Time, that one is sold out.

kayastar357 in r/Ulta

July 30, 2026 11:32 PM

5

10 by Spring: Update 4 🌻

No new updates, just chugging along. Mac Brushblack eyeliner. Still just feels neverending. Mac Modesty lipstick. Used a lot! Less than half remaining. The lipstick’s connection to the base is loose and it’s getting annoying to use. Rem brow pencil. Used several times. About half an inch ish remaini

...

EverImpractical in r/MakeupRehab

February 21, 2026 11:48 AM

6

What’s your current holy grail lip product? (Oils, stains, lipsticks, etc.)

Aquaphor for healing. The Cover Girl tinted lip balm in Bliss You Berry if I’m in a drying climate. MAC lipsticks in Syrup and Modesty for everyday looks.

Mystery-Moon_0129 in r/Makeup

March 19, 2026 3:29 PM

6

Redditors compare it with

Top alternatives in Lipstick

#1