Cremesheen Lipstick - Modesty

MAC

Cremesheen Lipstick - Modesty

64 positive 3 neutral 18 negative

Based on 85 Reddit mentions

$32.36

Buy on Amazon

We may earn a small commission.

Most discussed features

Sentiment summary across the product areas Reddit users mention most.

Reddit mentions

Original Reddit posts and comments behind this analysis.

Filtered by featureformula qualityClear feature

For the cool toned girlies

I saw this on Instagram the other day and laughed. I love cooler toned lipsticks and MAC has my favorite formula that doesn't irritate my lips but I do not own any of these lol. Syrup, mehr, modesty, be my bridesmaid, girls weekend, and faux all look nice on me!

UptownEgg in r/Sephora

March 5, 2026 3:00 AM

7

What are your favourite lip colours?

NYX soft matte lip cream in Rome, Bobbi Brown crushed lipstick in telluride cranberry, and ruby. Mac lip pencils in Whirl and Mahogany, mahogany is too dark I blur it out and it's perfect. Mac lipsticks, velvet teddy new and old formula, cool teddy, warm teddy, Taupe old formula only, modesty old fo

...

AdSweet3451 in r/Fairolives

June 14, 2026 4:36 PM

5

Cool toned lip products💄

Lipsticks are hard for me. I’m a true summer. But I’m fair olive. So I have to go more purple. Lipsticks I Love: -MAC Mehr -MAC Modesty new formula (maybe better for a soft summer but it is really close to the color of my lips). -MAC Alone Time -Revlon Laidback Lilac -Maybelline Lifter Glaze in Berr

...

NewMoonDweller in r/SummerType

December 16, 2025 3:44 AM

6

What’s your favourite discontinued lipstick?

Tom Ford pulling Indian Rose was a crime honestly. That shade had no business being that perfect for muted cool skin. Haven't found a real dupe but mac's modesty gets close if you layer it over a slightly darker liner. It's not the same formula though, the tom ford one had that blurring thing going

...

AdOutrageous1794 in r/PaleMUA

August 8, 2026 6:59 PM

2

Deinfluence my cart/help me pick my first Mac lipsticks!

You’re welcome! Here is the swatch, and I gave my best to swatch them in order of mentioning 😁 https://imgur.com/a/HTYqiJU Top row: Alone Time, Hug Me, Blankety, Modesty, Creme in Your Coffee Bottom row: Viva Planet, Honeylove, Velvet Teddy, Cool Teddy, Dubbonet, Thanks it’s MAC Hope this helps! P.s

...

fireplacegoddess3297 in r/OliveMUA

May 29, 2026 7:40 AM

2

Which lip color for the big day?

See the colour in 2 is your shade but the formulation looks like a dryer stain which isn’t so flattering and will flake. Either 2 with a gloss that you’ll need to touch up a lot or find a similar pinky shade of lipstick that’s a crème/more glossy/satin/shimmer finish to it I think. 3 Is close but to

...

856077 in r/Brides

July 27, 2026 9:22 AM

1

Desaturated Cool Nudes

The key problem is most colors labeled 'nude' have brown in them, and if you are extremely fair, all browns will be too dark. So you actually need to reconcile yourself to muted pinks. I'd recommend MAC as a starting point, though CT Pillow Talk Fair is also one to consider: Some ideas, and importan

...

Peridot31 in r/MakeupAddiction

July 29, 2026 6:12 PM

1

Faves and Fails Friday

I don’t have anything new this week, so I’m going to go through my favorites for the upcoming 21 Days of Beauty sale (Aug 29th) Olaplex 3 Kitsch satin pillow cases Clinique Black Honey Almost Lipstick IGK Good Behavior Urban Decay Primer Potion MAC lipstick- Blankety, Modesty, Cool Teddy, Soar, Whir

...

BabyYodasMacaron in r/muacjdiscussion

August 17, 2025 8:00 PM

2

Redditors compare it with

Top alternatives in Lipstick

#1