Mammut
Smart 2.0
$49.95
Edelrid
Based on 67 Reddit mentions
$110.00
Summary of sentiment across key features mentioned by users.
Discover what users really think based on Reddit discussions.
I'm old school and have fully switched. I use the Edelrid Pinch and the Edelrid Giga Jul. Good form and diligence are hugely important, but predictably fallible.
mehwolfy in r/ClimbingGear
January 16, 2026 2:59 PM
36
I’m just wondering if there is an official or best way of disengaging the cam as a lefty. here is an illustration from page 2 of the user manual. it does not get any more official than that, does it? and it is the best way in my experience. and there is a demonstration at 3:41 of this video by edelr
...max9265 in r/ClimbingGear
April 7, 2025 10:31 PM
12
All of those that you mentioned do exactly the same things: belay with single or double ropes, rappel on single or double ropes, and "guide mode" belay from the top anchor. They're all great, so you could pick any of them and be fine. Alternatively you could look into getting an assisted belay devic
...chewychubacca in r/ClimbingGear
September 2, 2025 12:56 PM
12
This question comes up twice a year, every year, probably based on course schedules. Climbing gear, especially belay devices, are pretty much optimized. Edelrid spent lots of time and money with people with decades of experience designing climbing gear and was able to make the pinch, which by popula
...Leading-Attention612 in r/climbing
September 7, 2025 2:15 PM
12
edelrid pinch is another option for assisted braking that’s slightly more similar to a tubular device in rope handling things like the mammut smart system do some braking but is geometry assisted not cam assisted (or passive vs mechanical?), probably very familiar to tube style but some more assista
...Long_jawn_silver in r/ClimbingGear
November 25, 2025 4:04 PM
6
Most versatile is definitely the edelrid giga jul. It's got assisted and standard modes, 2 rope slots for double ropes or rappelling, guide mode, and is pretty affordable. This is good if you want one device for literally everything. If you're only going to be doing single pitch sport, it's hard to
...Fluffydudeman in r/ClimbingGear
May 31, 2025 8:35 PM
11
I mean there are a lot of great devices out there and they are all safe. I really like my grigri but if I was going to get something new right now I liked the few times I played around with an edelrid pinch.
RealOneThisTime in r/ClimbingGear
October 14, 2025 9:35 PM
4
Lots of people raving about the edelrid pinch atm
ClimbsNFlysThings in r/ClimbingGear
October 22, 2025 2:48 PM
4
I was single pitch ice cragging the other day and switched from a Edelrid pinch (ABD) to my dmm pivot bc the ropes got icy and it was safer to use the pivot (ATC style). I usually bring my pivot with me when multi-pitching and leave the pinch in the car. TLDR: ATCs haven’t been replaced. Icy ropes a
...Nasuhhea in r/ClimbingGear
January 16, 2026 4:14 PM
4
My go-tos: Ocùn for harnesses (great value, awesome fit, surprisingly light) and a somewhat different shoe shape than the big brands. Fixe for ropes. I’m in love with the Siurana and Rodellar. Wonderful stretch and great handling. Boreal for shoes (because they’re the one brand that really fits my f
...Temporary_Spread7882 in r/climbergirls
August 17, 2025 11:11 PM
6