5.0/MG

WHOOP

5.0/MG

#8 in Fitness Trackers
192 positive 6 neutral 140 negative

Based on 338 Reddit mentions

What people say about

Summary of sentiment across key features mentioned by users.

fitness tracking

145/58

heart rate accuracy

68/44

comfort

56/11

price

24/41

software quality

40/23

subscription model

16/42

sleep tracking

50/5

durability

19/27

What people are saying

Discover what users really think based on Reddit discussions.

Sort by

Joined the Ultra fam!! 🙋🏼‍♀️

Whoop ticked me off with their 5.0/MG shenanigans so I decided to go all-in on Apple. This thing is gorgeous - and doesn’t look nearly as unwieldy on my (female) wrist as I thought it might!!

beyondsection17 in r/applewatchultra

May 20, 2025 7:27 PM

235

Thoughts on 5.0 Upgrade from Ben Foster, former Chief Product Officer at Whoop

I think most people understand that developing a new product costs a lot of money and I think a lot of us are willing to pay for that new product as long as they feel like Whoop cares about us. I believe that people at Whoop care about the end customer but I definitely didn’t feel that way this week

...

ClimateFew2414 in r/whoop

May 12, 2025 12:58 AM

220

No-screen wearable showdown v2: WHOOP MG 5.0, Oura 4, P0lar365/L00p, Garmin Instinct 3, Helio strap

Hi folks,
I am back with a longer term comparison between the most popular no-screen wearables.

TL;DR

  • RHR trends align very well across brands.
  • HRV trends align well for Helio, Oura, WHOOP, Polar. Garmin HRV trend is the outlier in my data.
  • Sleep duration is consistently measured across all
...
Image 1Image 2Image 3Image 4Image 5Image 6
+2 more

Born-Duty1335 in r/whoop

September 9, 2025 9:18 PM

187

[MegaThread] Clarifying and Updating Our Upgrade Policy

“Oh that blog post we posted a while back, yea we changed our mind. That’s not our policy because it doesn’t suit us now and we screwed up” That’s how this reads and that’s not exactly how any trading standards agency will see it. You cannot sell a product for years and years with pretence of free u

...

StrateJ in r/whoop

May 10, 2025 5:37 AM

139

After rage-quitting Whoop, I'm back.

I was one of the people who, angry about the way Whoop handled the 5.0/MG launch, rage-quit and switched to an apple watch. Even after the "upgrade fee" issue was resolved for users like me who had a long subscription remaining, I was still mad that upgrading would mean I would lose all the bands I

...

beyondsection17 in r/whoop

September 26, 2025 3:34 PM

137

Apple Watch Ultra 3 - Full Scientific Review (Apple Did It!)

The Apple Watch Ultra 3 delivers some of the most accurate health and fitness tracking ever tested, according to The Quantified Scientist. In controlled experiments comparing it to professional reference equipment, it achieved near-perfect heart rate tracking (R = 1.00) during indoor cycling and exc

...

Purple-Profit in r/apple

October 15, 2025 5:59 PM

136

Half‑marathon heart‑rate comparison: WHOOP 5.0 MG, Polar Loop, Amazfit Helio Strap, Garmin Enduro 3 vs Polar H10

As promised in the previous comparison - Three months with WHOOP MG 5.0, Oura 4, Polar365/Loop, Garmin Instinct 3, Helio strap - here’s the follow‑up focused on half‑marathon heart‑rate measurement.

I also incorporated feedback from the last post; this time I included the Polar H10 as a reference

...
Image 1Image 2Image 3Image 4Image 5Image 6
+1 more

Born-Duty1335 in r/whoop

November 17, 2025 7:34 AM

136

Extremely disappointed with WHOOP 5 — new bands don’t fit by a fraction of a millimeter. Seriously?

This comment on another post showed how to file down a 4.0 strap to work with the 5.0 https://www.reddit.com/r/whoop/s/24FvE8WvD3 It's crazy how small the difference is, they definitely should have just made the bands compatible. If their subscription costs don't cover their business costs and they

...

helldogskris in r/whoop

May 14, 2025 11:10 AM

120

Former WHOOP CPO: Summarizing What I Heard and My Honest Reflections and Forward-Looking Thoughts

That’s crazy how Apple has changed the size of the Apple Watch, even introducing a gigantic model, and the bands they introduced over 10 years ago still work! Changing the “form factor” is a poor excuse. Whoop has a few sensors but overall the most important one is the optical HR one, and this was n

...

ConstructionFun6757 in r/whoop

May 13, 2025 4:24 AM

117

Just got my Whoop age

Just got my Whoop 5.0 MG. Hoping to be younger on my Whoop Age than my actual age. Disappointed but not really surprised. i’m 76.4, 3.4 years more than I actually am. Not all bad news. My pace of ageing is in the right direction so I am getting younger. I know some of this is strength training which

...

MensHour in r/whoop

May 18, 2025 10:09 AM

105