ScanWatch

Withings

ScanWatch

91 positive 5 neutral 49 negative

Based on 145 Reddit mentions

$369.99

Buy on Amazon

We may earn a small commission.

Most discussed features

Sentiment summary across the product areas Reddit users mention most.

Reddit mentions

Original Reddit posts and comments behind this analysis.

Filtered by featuresleep trackingClear feature

Positively surprised by REM Tracking functionality in the latest Scanwatch Update

I own an Apple Watch and a Withings ScanWatch 2, and since the update, I've honestly been wearing the Withings watch much more again. It used to just lie in the closet, and I would put it on from time to time because it's so pretty to look at. But for the past few days, I've been extremely happy wit

...

Strandkorn12 in r/withings

October 16, 2025 3:47 PM

7

Withings Sleep Analyser

Works fine for me. Readings are relatively consistent between Withings Sleep Analyzer (or "Sleep" in the app?), ScanWatch Nova, and Oura Ring 4, although I mostly trust Oura on my sleep metrics. Heart rate, HRV, breathing rate, movement and sleep apnea readings are pretty consistent, but sleep phase

...

Informal_Car3267 in r/withings

October 13, 2025 7:38 AM

4

I thought I was the only one dissatisfied with my Withings devices, app, and subscription

So I've spent the last few days with a Garmin Vivo Sport and it ticks most of the boxes that were really annoying me about the Scanwatch and the Pininfarina Sintesi, but with some important caveats. Tl;dr I prefer it functionally but it doesn't have the premium watch feel. The good: The app's better

...

Exact_Wrongdoer in r/withings

December 3, 2025 6:15 PM

2

To all ex-AW owners, what makes the Garmin a better watch for you than the AW?

Ex AW user of many different types, switching back and forth and generally undecided. Like you say, sleep tracking is not that great and has a major impact on the Body Battery and Training readiness. It seems to me that Garmin is currently improving in that area, my scores are getting better without

...

mat_rhein in r/GarminWatches

June 11, 2025 12:17 PM

3

Devices that add data?

Withings devices (in their most recent active versions) have FDA clearance for atrial fibrillation detection, sleep apnea diagnosis, and blood pressure monitoring. Specifically, the ScanWatch received clearance for ECG and SpO2 measurements for atrial fibrillation detection, and the Sleep Rx mat was

...

redhawkhoosier in r/AppleWatch

June 13, 2025 1:02 AM

3

Scan watch 2 or Apple Watch

the scanwatch is the only one to detect paradoxical sleep and naps. The sleep score of the Appel watch is ridiculous compared to withings.

martox80 in r/withings

October 8, 2025 6:53 PM

3

ScanWatch 2 worth it for $110?

I like my Scanwatch watches and I have two of them. The prior generation in white and the Horizon version in green. They do a fine job with simple notifications. I rely on neither for any kind of health tracking, step tracking, or sleep tracking. They are the watches I put on when I'm going out to d

...

cbelliott in r/withings

October 26, 2025 5:40 AM

2

very disappointed with Scanwatch 2

over the last few years, I got these: Withings Steel HR: nice looking but clunky user interface - clearly a work in progress on their part, Huawei Watch GT: autonomy sounded good but it turns out what I really wanted was a watch with proper physical hands, Fossil Collider: good looking from far, not

...

ozumar in r/withings

July 22, 2025 10:05 AM

2

New to Garmin

I’m having a hard time finding the study I read comparing the 3 of them as it was a few years ago. But there are some studies I was able find that still show the measure of Garmin accuracy to be less accurate than every other tracker: “The worst-performing devices were the two Garmins, which ranked

...

s3an99 in r/GarminWatches

September 19, 2025 1:57 PM

2

Almost no deep sleep

Same. I have used Withings and an Huawei smart watch each night for a few weeks after I noticed this and get very different results. The Huawei watch is more correct. Withings added REM-sleep and if you add both REM and deep sleep together it seems to be more close to the time my Huawei registers fo

...

milky81 in r/withings

November 14, 2025 9:38 AM

2

Top alternatives in Smartwatches

#1