#1
Tarte
Maneater Mascara
30 positive 0 neutral 2 negative
Based on 32 Reddit mentions
$15.00
Buy on Amazon
We may earn a small commission.
Most discussed features
Sentiment summary across the product areas Reddit users mention most.
Reddit mentions
Original Reddit posts and comments behind this analysis.
Makeup products that ended up sucking (for you)
The Tarte Maneater mascara was my biggest waste of money. The brush was great, but the mascara was absolute trash. No matter what I did it just crumbled all over my eyes. I think it may actually be the worst mascara I have ever used.
Pieclops89 in r/Makeup
February 12, 2026 3:51 AM
9
DISCUSSION: Wednesday Makeup Declutter! Let's discuss your recent declutters.
I got rid of the tarte maneater mascara. I had it in a mini size and got it for free with purchase maybe like 3 years ago. I’ve tried using it up (it was ok, wouldn’t repurchase) but it absolutely sucked lol and dried up so fast inside the tube. I had to moisten it a few times with eye drops just be
...curlyhairthickthighs in r/PanPorn
October 22, 2025 4:46 PM
5
