#1
MAC
Cremesheen Lipstick - Modesty
53 positive 0 neutral 16 negative
Based on 69 Reddit mentions
$33.94
Buy on Amazon
We may earn a small commission.
Most discussed features
Sentiment summary across the product areas Reddit users mention most.
Reddit mentions
Original Reddit posts and comments behind this analysis.
Mauve lipsticks on my NC15ish cool-leaning olive skin
I should also add that I am a MAC lipstick encyclopedia. Any permanent MAC lipstick going as far back as 1990 - I have tried it and/or own it. All of the original cremesheens were too warm for me (including modesty and creme in your coffee) other than hot gossip, which was still way too bright. For
...exileinwhoville in r/Fairolives
August 29, 2025 10:15 PM
6
Can someone explain the color theory why Mac Modesty looks like this on this person but ashy/gray on me?
Okay this bothered me so much I uploaded comparisons to Rituel de Fille Hex (a lipstick that is supposed to be lavender, but ends up pink due to my yellow tones): https://imgur.com/a/xvT2UAg u/OkSignificance4856 justice for us cool girlies! The new Mac Modesty is orange and brown on me. I honestly t
...lil-rosa in r/Fairolives
January 13, 2026 5:05 AM
2
