Tarantula Pro

I switched to a GameSir Tarantula Pro recently after my 8bitdo pro 3 died (broken trigger, which is a big hazard in this game). It's been very good. 9 extra buttons that can be mapped to a different button or to a keyboard key, or to a combo of buttons/keys. I map dpad left and right to the back pad

Correct. Genuine Xbox controllers don't have gyro. My recommended alternative is a GameSir Tarantula Pro but you'll still need an application to leverage either the controller or the device gyro. Microsoft has no native support for any of them yet.

PS4 controller is great, whether or not you get drift is kind of a crapshoot. I had a ps4 controller that lasted around a year before it got drift. I’ve been on a quest to find the perfect rocket league controller and have spent way too much money, to the point where I’m seriously brainstorming how