They're Real

Benefit Cosmetics

They're Real

69 positive 1 neutral 18 negative

Based on 88 Reddit mentions

$23.50

Buy on Amazon

We may earn a small commission.

Most discussed features

Sentiment summary across the product areas Reddit users mention most.

Reddit mentions

Original Reddit posts and comments behind this analysis.

Filtered by featureoverall qualityClear feature

What are the worst products that you bought in 2025?

That stupid fucking bounce mascara from benefit. Literally back to back to back amazing mascara releases (they’re real, roller lash, badgal bang) then this dry, flaky nightmare that if I apply at 10:43 covers my under eyes in dried product by 11:00am sharp. To hell.

unique_plastique in r/Sephora

January 9, 2026 12:26 AM

77

How do I stop this from happening by the end of the day?!

Better than Sex is awful, one of the few mascaras that smudges and flakes on me no matter what I do. Try Mac Stack, Benefit They're Real, Diorshow or any by Maybelline and you'll see the difference.

Chernyyvoron82 in r/MakeupAddiction

June 5, 2025 6:43 AM

143

What do we think of Aldi makeup?

I used that one too. It’s a dupe of Benefit They’re Real and performs ok. I have moved over to tubing mascaras because I’m oily and use drops throughout the day and don’t want to encourage smudging. I still might get another anyway because I remember liking it.

SabaSMelaku in r/aldi

May 1, 2026 12:53 AM

11

How to keep eyelashes from clumping together?

Tinted lash primer is a game changer! I use the Benefit They're Real tinted lash primer in brown. For my top lashes, I coat with the primer, separate the lashes with a spoolie, fill in my lash line with a brown liquid eyeliner, then go back in with a dark brown or black mascara and separate with a s

...

AndYouHaveAPizza in r/MakeupAddiction

December 31, 2025 5:56 PM

14

Mascara recommendation

Get the travel-size (mini) from Benefit Cosmetics (either Bag Gal Bang! or They're Real). I think the Bad Gal Bang is the absolute best mascara on the market, doesn't flake, and is not too overpowering/heavy on the lashes. And they offer minis, which honestly last me for months. However, as with any

...

fancygppy in r/Makeup

April 21, 2026 9:02 AM

4

Rant: Worst mascara ever?

There are two that come to mind that I have. Too Faced Better than Sex - Heavy, clumpy and weighs the lashes down. Too Faced should reformulate this instead of wasting so much on the different packaging. Benefit They're Real - Dry and flaky and doesn't do much in my opinion. This was surprising to m

...

Exotic-Bumblebee2753 in r/Makeup

July 4, 2025 5:39 PM

15

Mascara recommendations?

I am obsessed with Benefit Cosmetics mascaras. So much so that I refuse to buy anything else, they're just THAT good. My favorite right now is Bad Girl BANG! but have used They're Real for years too and it's very good. But Bad Girl BANG! lifts so beautifully and keeps the lashes dreamy all day long.

...

fancygppy in r/Sephoracanada

November 23, 2025 11:55 PM

5

Since when is elf actually good?

I was sent this mascara from ipsy it’s the benefit they’re real and oh my god it is so lengthening and gorgeous, not too sheer not too clumpy

Remarkable_Loan_3338 in r/MakeupAddiction

February 2, 2026 2:33 AM

5

what’s an expensive makeup product that you don’t regret buying?

Tatcha the silk primer (in the compact)! This looks amazing with any foundation but love it with Kat Von D good apple foundation (in round flat container, but must specifically be used with the Tatcha primer!). Goes on smooth & great coverage without using too much and no cakiness! Estée Lauder doub

...

LisaLaggrrr in r/Makeup

October 22, 2025 9:07 AM

5

Products that got bumped off your holy grail list after it was reformulated?

Benefit “They’re Real” mascara used to be my holy grail for probably 10 years. Ever since they reformulated it, it smudges, dries out super fast, and flakes everywhere. So disappointing because the original formula was so good. I stopped using it well over a year ago and switched to Armani “Vertigo”

...

Serious_Group_6559 in r/Sephora

May 18, 2026 3:26 PM

3

Redditors compare it with

Top alternatives in Mascara

#1