Loop

Polar

Loop

146 positive 5 neutral 140 negative

Based on 291 Reddit mentions

$199.99

Buy on Amazon

We may earn a small commission.

Most discussed features

Sentiment summary across the product areas Reddit users mention most.

Reddit mentions

Original Reddit posts and comments behind this analysis.

Filtered by featuredesignClear feature

What happened to Polar?

Polar's problems are bigger than the US, and their decline significantly predates the current US administration. Long story short: they stopped innovating. Flow hasn't seen any real updates in a decade; entire product lines (e.g. cycling computers) have been canceled, the software in their devices i

...

sathomasga in r/Polarfitness

November 25, 2025 7:37 PM

18

Apple Watch to Polar Loop, day 1 – Surprisingly good

Workout auto detection on the Apple Watch operates on movement patterns, not heart rate spikes. The watch looks for a specific, consistent motion sustained for a certain period of time, on the Apple Watch 11 it’s roughly ten minutes, before it triggers an automatic workout notification but it also t

...

ObjectiveReality1895 in r/Polarfitness

July 7, 2026 9:48 PM

5

Polar - the future or perhaps just the past?

The Polar Flow app is a disaster. I have tested Fitbit Air, the Whoop Helio Strap, and the Polar Loop, as well as numerous smartwatches and smart rings. Polar just doesn’t make sense to me. The app looks like software from the 90s. I’m missing a well‑designed overview, and every time I open the app,

...

Lost_Building_2251 in r/Polarfitness

July 9, 2026 3:45 PM

3

Polar loop thoughts

To me, the Polar brand was the gold standard of accuracy, but I have felt that the Loop (when worn on the wrist) lacked accuracy compared to my Apple Watch. Plus, I got used to haptic alarms, which the Loop is lacking. I went back to the watch. I then started experimenting with biceps bands and conf

...

Not-a-sugar3 in r/Polarfitness

May 9, 2026 11:00 PM

2

Its here! Polar Loop Gen2.

I rarely write posts like this, but this one deserves it. This is my honest review 6 months after buying it (yes, i was one of the guys trusting Polar with this new product straightaway). I bought the Polar Loop thinking I’d get a simple, minimal, screen-free tracker. What I got instead is a frustra

...

0YODA0 in r/Polarfitness

April 11, 2026 11:12 AM

2

Just joined the polar team with a Loop

The actual calories should be somewhere in between the two values. Generally speaking, Garmin tends to understimate while Polar trends to overestimate but I would say it is likely closer to Garmin than Polar considering that calorie counting also depends on heart rate accuracy and the heart rate mon

...

Much-Internal7823 in r/Polarfitness

April 2, 2026 7:19 AM

2

Street X megathread

Don't think they sent them to any bigger names in advance, but please correct me if I'm wrong isn't it basically an all plastic M3 except last gen sensor, no maps, no ECG, no o2? Not sure what's really to review if I'm honest. It's a decent price point for the features, love the flashlight finally,

...

Grumpy_Squatch in r/Polarfitness

April 2, 2026 11:01 PM

2

Polar loop experience is really disappointing

I had using Polar Loop for a few days. Extremely disappointing!! First of all, it kept on syncing but lost connection. I switched on the “auto detection” but it failed to detect anything. Then, I simply went for a WALK and forced it to record an activity with Phone GPS on. It gave an unacceptable gr

...

NefariousnessStrict1 in r/Polarfitness

April 4, 2026 3:35 AM

2

Polar Loop ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Polar war einst eine führende Marke - heute ist Sie leider nur ein Schatten dessen, was Sie mal war. Eigentlich eine schöne Idee so ein Polar Loop. Die Umsetzung ist nicht gut.

Warm_Purchase218 in r/Polarfitness

August 10, 2026 6:42 AM

1

Just joined the polar team with a Loop

But that is not really a current heart rate feature but a workaround of Polar Loop lacking such a feature. The start tab is meant to be used to track exercise. But then it is also silly to get a screenless device when you are interested in continious heart rate tracking. Which is probably why Polar

...

Much-Internal7823 in r/Polarfitness

April 2, 2026 7:10 AM

1

Top alternatives in Fitness Trackers

#1