Great Lash

Maybelline

Great Lash

103 positive 0 neutral 24 negative

Based on 127 Reddit mentions

$6.82

Buy on Amazon

We may earn a small commission.

Most discussed features

Sentiment summary across the product areas Reddit users mention most.

Reddit mentions

Original Reddit posts and comments behind this analysis.

Filtered by featureformulaClear feature

52681

any with a shitty, non-waterproof formula will work. Maybelline great lash is notoriously good for this because of how runny it's consistency is.

Outrageous_Term3923 in r/countwithchickenlady

May 30, 2026 7:08 PM

33

help me choose a mascara

This is painful even to read. Mascara should not be removing your eyelashes you've got to be extremely gentle and only buy water-based mascaras that will come off with a gentle soap and water. I learned that all makeup removers are harsh I use Dove soap and water if a stubborn mascara won't come off

...

Impossible_Range8813 in r/Makeup

July 17, 2026 2:23 AM

3

What are your favourite mascaras that don't smuge or flake?

People hate on Maybelline Great Lash- but the BIG formula specifically, and wand have been my holy grail for like 20 years. I’ve tried so many high and low ends over the years and this is the only one that never smudges or flakes on me throughout the day, and even if I go into the ocean or cry unexp

...

heydelinquent in r/drugstoreMUA

April 24, 2026 7:52 PM

3

Put in contacts and wore mascara, immediately got a stye

Not a contacts-wearer, but I was getting styes like crazy for a while and I found switching to a drier mascara formula helped a lot (I really like the clear Maybelline Great Lash, but I think the sort of tacky/viscous formula was clogging up my eyelash follicles or holding on to like microscopic deb

...

catfacedbitch in r/rs_x

April 27, 2026 4:14 PM

3

For women who NEVER wear makeup, what lead you to that choice?

I love wearing eyeshadow and eyeliner and highlighter and blush, but I hate mascara. I like the Maybelline great lash in pink and green tube because it’s mostly tint. Anything thicker and I crunch it off while listening to meetings. But crossed lashes need love. Get a spoolie brush. It’ll help keep

...

captaintagart in r/AskReddit

August 3, 2026 4:24 AM

1

What is a good mascara that doesn't cost an arm and a leg?

People will disagree with me, but... Maybelline Great Lash in very black Trust me, as a girl with light, fine hair, this stuff has come through for me every time! Edit to add: Getting it in VERY black is very important, NOT BLACKEST black. Blackest Black has an extremely watery formula that complete

...

RidleeRiddle in r/MakeupAddiction

August 3, 2026 9:34 AM

1

How the hell does make up work?

Before you start, wash your face. Applying a toner or serum is optional, but can be a nice bonus for whatever additional stuff you want for your skin. Moisturizer and sunscreen are not optional, however. Let the moisturizer sit for a few minutes to soak in, then dab off the excess with a tissue. It'

...

FascinatedHelix in r/MakeupAddiction

July 23, 2026 10:04 PM

1

Mascara for sensitive eyes?

I have very sensitive eyes and have had a good experience with the basic Maybelline great lash

perfect-night-skies in r/MakeupAddiction

April 3, 2026 12:52 PM

1

Top alternatives in Mascara

#1