Monsieur Big

Have you tried Lancome's Monsieur Big waterproof? It's what I use. It doesn't flake or smudge and it's buildable. Forgive me, but I don't know what a tubing mascara is. I tried to Google it, but I think I'm too tired to wrap my mind around the concept. I'm sorry.

Monsieur Big by Lancome or Lash Idole by Lancome Both a little pricey, but zero issues with either one!

Lancome Monsieur Big Waterproof. I am outside alot and have short blonde lashes. This is a the best mascara I've ever used. Never have a smearing issue and lashes are long and beautiful. I use a plain brush to separate the lashes sometimes, but that's a minor occasional issue.

Lancome Monsieur BIG mascara. It doesn't clump, it doesn't smear under my eyes, and it makes me look like I behave eyelashes with one coat. If I'm going out, I curl my eyelashes, use 1 coat of Cils Booster and 2 coats of the Monsiuer BIG. But for everyday, one coat is all I need. LOVE this mascara!

Lancome Monsieur Big Waterproof and L'Oreal Paradise Big Deal Waterproof are not smudging on me. Sadly, a lot of waterproof mascaras are not so waterproof and smudge on me. But those two work great.

Lancome monsieur big (waterproof), Loreal telescopic (waterproof), Rom&nd volume black, Clio kill lash, Heroine Make. I wouldn’t mind only being able to use 1 of these for the rest of my life. the last 3 brands all perform very similarly (for me at least, I have oily eyelids)