Roller Lash

Benefit Cosmetics

Roller Lash

100 positive 0 neutral 24 negative

Based on 124 Reddit mentions

$23.99

Buy on Amazon

We may earn a small commission.

Most discussed features

Sentiment summary across the product areas Reddit users mention most.

Reddit mentions

Original Reddit posts and comments behind this analysis.

Filtered by featurevalueClear feature

Benefit Brow Prices Are Crazy

I know this post is about their brow services but I'm still sad about the roller lash mascara. They got me hooked on it when it first came out and I used to be able to consistently snag it for $12 during their 21 DOB sales. Now it's my staple and I'm stuck paying $29 every time! Really wish it was m

...

melinda_louise in r/Ulta

April 7, 2026 11:00 AM

4

I am MTF and have never tried make up, what looks might suit my face the best? I want to learn some "everyday" looks, and maybe have a few fun look ideas to play with too

I also thought “oh wow I’d never have known” go through my head! You are freaking stunning. I’m honestly envious of your hair in that second pic. I have no makeup tips except don’t be afraid of mascara, because as a tomboy cis woman that’s come to makeup late, that’s actually always been the easiest

...

RojoFox in r/MakeupAddiction

February 7, 2026 8:57 PM

2

What makeup product did you stop buying because the cheaper version worked better?

Dropped Benefit Roller Lash for ELF Lash N Roll

Nagadavida in r/MakeupAddiction

December 22, 2025 11:59 PM

1

How would you do my makeup?

Individual lashes/small clusters are going in different yet very distinct directions that are not congruent with the others. It doesn't look like a natural lift or curl pattern. This happened to me when I learned to use a lash curler as effectively as possible, which definitely seems to be the case

...

Daphne6624 in r/MakeupAddiction

January 31, 2026 5:15 AM

1

Easy to remove mascara that is NOT a tubing mascara?

I really like benefits roller lash. I usually buy it when it goes on sale for $12 or half price at ulta.

princesssamc in r/Makeup

February 16, 2026 9:57 PM

1

What is your hg mascara in 2026

I still really like Benefit Roller Lash. I just want a touch of mascara to highlight my lashes, I don’t want huge, thick black lashes that look like false ones. Plus I can buy the travel size as I just don’t get through a full size one. I only wish they did a brown shade too as black is a bit harsh

...

Calm-Bus7555 in r/MakeUpAddictionUK

April 7, 2026 4:18 PM

1

Best mascaras that actually worked for you?

I like the it cosmetics superhero one and roller lash by benefit but the it cosmetics is good if the budget is too tight for the higher end ones

Halloedangel in r/beauty

April 8, 2026 8:40 PM

1

Best Mascara 2025 for Daily Use, Long Lashes, Volume, and Sensitive Eye-Friendly Options

Benefit Roller Lash makes my lashes super long and fluttery. Maybelline Lash Sensational gives a similar look, not quite as good, but it’s the best one if you are on budget.

FunctionFluid9299 in r/BeautyItemsReview

September 29, 2025 12:52 PM

1

Mascara that won’t budge but also won’t make my lashes fall out 😭

benefits roller lash makes my lashes look so good and is similar in price to your current mascara. i also use elf’s lash xtender and that works well. also are you using an oil cleanser or balm to remove it? whenever i use those it makes my eyelashes less likely to fall out

web-core in r/MakeupAddiction

October 24, 2025 2:02 PM

1

Good black brown mascara that doesnt smudge/run?

I LOVE the ELF Lash n Roll. It's natural, absolutely clump free, and buildable, and seriously underdiscussed imo. I have it in brown and black and find myself wearing the brown every natural/no-makeup day. EDIT: did not know about ELF controversy. I'm not buying it, either, screw that. If it helps,

...

anoukaimee in r/drugstoreMUA

September 12, 2025 12:21 AM

-2

Top alternatives in Mascara

#1