my picks are either go all out and get a GriGri (not the plus) or a BD ATC Pilot, Mammut Smart 2.0
Tight-Instruction880 in r/ClimbingGear
SourceMammut Smart vs Black Diamond ATC
Reddit head-to-head
6 Reddit comments and posts discuss both products: 5 lean toward Mammut Smart, 1 toward Black Diamond ATC, and 0 don't pick a side.
Mammut Smart · 5 Neutral · 0 Black Diamond ATC · 1
Why Redditors pick the Mammut Smart
these are all devices that are objectively better for belaying
Thirtysevenintwenty5 in r/climbing
Sourceany brake assisted plate style device: Mammut Smart, Black Diamond ATC Pilot etc
Senor_del_Sol in r/ClimbingGear
SourceWhy Redditors pick the Black Diamond ATC
the Pilot is the better option for most first devices IMO
BostonFartMachine in r/ClimbingGear
SourceFeature comparison
Green marks the row winner: the strongest supported feature sentiment with at least 3 mentions, or the lowest listed price. Everything else stays neutral.
Mammut Smart
60 Reddit mentions
$51.17
Buy on Amazon
We may earn a small commission.
Black Diamond ATC
33 Reddit mentions
$54.95
Buy on Amazon
We may earn a small commission.
ease of use
braking performance
versatility
rope handling
safety
lowering control
design
durability
weight
guide mode
| Feature | Mammut Smart | Black Diamond ATC |
|---|---|---|
| Price | ||
| ease of use | | |
| braking performance | | |
| versatility | | |
| rope handling | | |
| safety | | |
| lowering control | | |
| design | | |
| durability | | |
| weight | | |
| guide mode | | |
Products
#2
Buy on Amazon
We may earn a small commission.
#5
Buy on Amazon
We may earn a small commission.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better according to Reddit: Mammut Smart or Black Diamond ATC?
6 Reddit comments and posts discuss both products: 5 lean toward Mammut Smart, 1 toward Black Diamond ATC, and 0 don't pick a side. Overall, Reddit leans toward Mammut Smart.
How do Mammut Smart and Black Diamond ATC compare in overall Reddit sentiment?
Across all discussions RedDB tracks, Mammut Smart has 93% positive sentiment over 60 Reddit mentions, while Black Diamond ATC has 76% positive sentiment over 33 mentions.