my picks are either go all out and get a GriGri (not the plus) or a BD ATC Pilot, Mammut Smart 2.0
Tight-Instruction880 in r/ClimbingGear
SourceMammut Smart vs Black Diamond ATC
Reddit head-to-head
6 Reddit comments and posts discuss both products: 5 lean toward Mammut Smart, 1 toward Black Diamond ATC, and 0 don't pick a side.
Mammut Smart · 5Neutral · 0Black Diamond ATC · 1
Why Redditors pick the Mammut Smart
these are all devices that are objectively better for belaying
Thirtysevenintwenty5 in r/climbing
Sourceany brake assisted plate style device: Mammut Smart, Black Diamond ATC Pilot etc
Senor_del_Sol in r/ClimbingGear
SourceWhy Redditors pick the Black Diamond ATC
the Pilot is the better option for most first devices IMO
BostonFartMachine in r/ClimbingGear
SourceFeature comparison
Green marks the row winner: the strongest supported feature sentiment with at least 3 mentions, or the lowest listed price. Everything else stays neutral.
Mammut Smart
61 Reddit mentions
$49.95
Buy on Amazon
We may earn a small commission.
Black Diamond ATC
35 Reddit mentions
$54.95
Buy on Amazon
We may earn a small commission.
ease of use
braking performance
versatility
rope handling
safety
lowering control
design
durability
weight
guide mode
| Feature | Mammut Smart | Black Diamond ATC |
|---|---|---|
| Price | ||
| ease of use | ||
| braking performance | ||
| versatility | ||
| rope handling | ||
| safety | ||
| lowering control | ||
| design | ||
| durability | ||
| weight | ||
| guide mode |
Products
#2
Mammut
$49.95
Smart
60.2/100
61 opinionsReddit score
RedDB's algorithmic rating based only on relevant Reddit opinions.
It uses one opinion per author: their highest-upvoted mention.
Evidence volume, recency, and votes affect the result.
The opinion count and sentiment bar include all analyzed relevant opinions; the bar does not represent the score out of 100.
57 positive0 neutral4 negative
Buy on Amazon
We may earn a small commission.
#7
Black Diamond
$54.95
ATC
56.2/100
35 opinionsReddit score
RedDB's algorithmic rating based only on relevant Reddit opinions.
It uses one opinion per author: their highest-upvoted mention.
Evidence volume, recency, and votes affect the result.
The opinion count and sentiment bar include all analyzed relevant opinions; the bar does not represent the score out of 100.
27 positive0 neutral8 negative
Buy on Amazon
We may earn a small commission.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better according to Reddit: Mammut Smart or Black Diamond ATC?
6 Reddit comments and posts discuss both products: 5 lean toward Mammut Smart, 1 toward Black Diamond ATC, and 0 don't pick a side. Overall, Reddit leans toward Mammut Smart.
How do Mammut Smart and Black Diamond ATC compare in overall Reddit sentiment?
Across all discussions RedDB tracks, Mammut Smart has 93% positive sentiment over 61 Reddit mentions, while Black Diamond ATC has 77% positive sentiment over 35 mentions.
More comparisons
Mammut Smart vs Mammut Smart 2.023 Reddit comments and posts discuss bothEdelrid Pinch vs Mammut Smart9 Reddit comments and posts discuss bothBlack Diamond ATC vs Black Diamond ATC-XP6 Reddit comments and posts discuss bothMammut Smart vs Edelrid Giga Jul4 Reddit comments and posts discuss bothMammut Smart vs Petzl Grigri4 Reddit comments and posts discuss bothMammut Smart vs Edelrid Jul 24 Reddit comments and posts discuss both