
Maybelline
$9.49

Charlotte Tilbury
RedDB rating based on Reddit opinions
Reddit score
RedDB's algorithmic rating based only on relevant Reddit opinions.
It uses one opinion per author: their highest-upvoted mention.
Evidence volume, recency, and votes affect the result.
The opinion count and sentiment bar include all analyzed relevant opinions; the bar does not represent the score out of 100.
$16.00
We may earn a small commission.
Sentiment summary across the product areas Reddit users mention most.
Original Reddit posts and comments behind this analysis.
OMG you guys! lol So I took the picture because I wanted a comparison of mascaras. I got a set of like 10 mini mascaras and I want to see which one will be the winner to buy a full size. Today is day 1 and the mascara I used is Charlotte Tilbury Exagger-eyes that I grabbed a mini of at the register
...Additional-Focus-123 in r/MakeupAddiction
April 20, 2026 at 9:47 PM
47
Almost everything from Charlotte Tilbury, with highly notable exceptions. Every skin care product results in a greasy feel. All the foundations, concealers, powders, blushes, lipsticks, and shadows are so dark, warm, and orange toned they make my very fair cool/olive look like I overdosed on early 0
...psdancecoach in r/Makeup
February 12, 2026 at 6:01 AM
18
Their OG Faux Cils was my Holy Grail mascara, but then they reformulated it and now it's just meh. 😭 I've been disappointed by all the other YSL mascara sub-brands I've tried, too. I recently switched to Charlotte Tilbury Exagger-eyes after a very long search for a replacement. It's the closest I've
...SaborDeVida in r/Sephora
January 31, 2026 at 1:17 AM
6
The REFY mascara is amazing and I’m on my 4th bottle; Defo the best. I pair it with the Charlotte Tilbury exagger-eyes for double the volume and neither smudge. More budget friendly options then use a L’Oréal one, but as a mascara fanatic I think the more expensive ones perform better (unfortunately
...Guilty_Loss7370 in r/MakeUpAddictionUK
July 11, 2026 at 8:26 AM
3
I know this might be controversial but I buy the charlotte tilbury exagger eyes mascara. It’s the only mascara that leaves the curl in my lash, buildable and has absolutely no fall out. I’ve wasted so much on drug store mascaras. My lashes would always end up straight and I’d have raccoon eyes after
...HelpMuahPlz in r/Makeup
February 25, 2026 at 11:07 AM
4
I really like Charlotte Tilbury’s Exagger-Eyes Volume Mascara. It’s a tubing formula, although it is pretty expensive. Honestly, Maybelline Sky High in the pink tube is also really good, even though it isn’t tubing. I find that both make my eyes look much more lifted and open, and they’re really eas
...Fun-Internal9671 in r/SkincareAddiction
July 20, 2026 at 3:40 PM
2
My current go to routine is very simple but when I want to go glam I add a few items in. My skin is normal to oily, somewhat sensitive and acne prone, light medium neutral olive (ever so slightly cool) for context Skin prep - this to me is the most important step to keep things looking fresh through
...Sorry-Beginning-7711 in r/MakeupAddiction
October 29, 2025 at 12:56 AM
3
Charlotte Tilbury- exagger -eyes volume mascara is a holy grail product for me!
Makeuplover1188 in r/Makeup
October 21, 2025 at 7:14 PM
2
I also answer this. :-) Restocks - Givenchy Pressed Powder, OUIA Shampoo and Conditioner, Tatcha Indigo Repair Cream Absolutely would not recommend the Rhode Pineapple Cleanser. Smells awful and made me break out. You should absolutely go get - The Patrick Ta Duo Eyeshadows. They are pretty, and the
...rayne_beldrulf in r/Sephora
November 16, 2025 at 4:58 AM
2
MAKEUP Tarte life lock setting spray: I love the cooling effect, but this didn’t work as well for me as Charlotte Tilbury. Benefit Porefessional matte primer: It’s great, but for me it’s too expensive - I don’t wear foundation daily. Charlotte Tilbury Exagger-eyes mascara: Very smudgy. Did not like.
...enjoythsilence in r/BeautyEmpties
January 1, 2026 at 8:13 PM
2

Maybelline
$9.49

Maybelline
$10.82

Lancome
$13.60