Come Hell Or Highwater Zero Smudge Clean Mascara

Caliray

Come Hell Or Highwater Zero Smudge Clean Mascara

62 positive 0 neutral 18 negative

Based on 80 Reddit mentions

$15.00

Buy on Amazon

We may earn a small commission.

Most discussed features

Sentiment summary across the product areas Reddit users mention most.

Reddit mentions

Original Reddit posts and comments behind this analysis.

Filtered by featuresmudge resistanceClear feature

Mascara that doesn’t smudge and lasts for 12+ hours? Yes please!!!

I'm a nurse that works 12-hour shifts and this is also what I use on the daily! It stays put but comes off sooo easily and the clumps are kinda satisfying lol. After a tiring shift, the last thing I want to do is to wrestle with waterproof formulas.đź« 

unanatkumot in r/AsianBeauty

June 1, 2026 12:08 PM

44

Mascara help!

Caliray Come Hell or High Water mascara is incredible. The stuff does not budge (until you’re ready to remove it). Hell, I cried in my car today and it is still completely intact and didn’t run or smudge.

HeyLegacy in r/Sephora

May 1, 2026 5:08 AM

13

What are you unsung hero products?

Caliray Come Hell or High Water mascara; separates the lashes really well and doesn’t flake or smear. It’s supposed to come off easy with water but I’ve actually worn this to the beach and swimming before and it stayed put, no smudging. Briogeo Curl Charisma Rice Amino + Avocado leave-in and Pattern

...

Curious_Doof in r/Sephora

June 18, 2026 6:31 PM

11

Mascara that doesn’t smudge and lasts for 12+ hours? Yes please!!!

Yeah, as far as I know such mascaras disintegrate more easily with warm-hot water, and when you cry tears are usually warm enough to make tubing mascara go away. But! it still stays longer than usual mascara (idk about waterproof, never tried) and doesn’t make such a mess on your eyes, just a bunch

...

rotermonh in r/AsianBeauty

June 1, 2026 8:55 PM

7

What are the best smudge-proof mascaras for a natural look?

I would go with a tubing mascara like Caliray or Tarte tubing. They are both natural looking and won’t smudge easily but wash off in the shower with ease.

g1zmo33 in r/Sephora

June 9, 2026 12:11 AM

7

Mascara that doesn’t smudge and lasts for 12+ hours? Yes please!!!

I have naturally long lashes and my eyelid area gets oily, so if I blink a lot before it fully dries or I don't put some lighter eye shadow/powder beneath my lower lashes, it will smudge. So while not fully smudgeproof for me, it does stay on the best for me compared to other mascaras.

Frequent_Safe1616 in r/AsianBeauty

June 1, 2026 3:37 PM

6

Mascara that doesn’t smudge and lasts for 12+ hours? Yes please!!!

Yes I have this and totally agree! However it is a bit annoying to remove hence not being my daily 🤣 should I put it to the test and put it through the sauna and steam room? Hehe

GasAdministrative124 in r/AsianBeauty

June 2, 2026 12:52 AM

4

Mascara Recommendations that don't smudge?

None of these have ever smudged on me: Covergirl Lash Blast, Ilia Limitless Length, YSL Lash Clash, Caliray Come Hell or High Water. Hope you find one that works for you!

Elle_the_Belle16 in r/MakeupAddiction

July 8, 2026 12:07 AM

3

How do you get your makeup to actually last all day without looking cakey?

It’s hard to give you advice without seeing it. My base often looks better as the day progresses. The most obvious thing is to prep your skin. Is it possible that your skin is dry? In the spirit of not gatekeeping I use the elf hydrating camo concealer (key word hydrating not the regular one). I let

...

That-Permission5758 in r/makeuptips

July 5, 2026 12:28 AM

2

Mascara comparable to maybelline lash sensation/sky high

Caliray come hell or high water is an amazing tubing mascara that I found was super similar, I started using it before i began my CF purchasing journey and was happy to find out the brand is cruelty free and leaping bunny certified. My only complaint is that the tube comes quite full which is great

...

Evening-Lack1800 in r/crueltyfree

June 14, 2026 8:21 PM

2

Top alternatives in Mascara

#1