Come Hell Or Highwater Zero Smudge Clean Mascara

Ironically, this was the only mascara that truly smudged on me a lot.

I have used this and although it stays on for a long time and holds a curl well, I find that it always gives me smudgy dark circles, even when I skip the bottom lashes! How do you get it to not smudge? Do you use a lash primer or something? Are my eyes greasy or something? I don’t get it.

This smudges for me!

Interesting! Haven’t had this problem at all, although I’ve experienced it with other mascaras. In my experience it’s a little TOO smudge proof. Maybe just not the right formula for you.

Yep. I used to love this. Then I found better mascaras. I stopped using makeup for years and had to buy some for work recently. I saw this was on sale for less than $7 and couldn’t remember why I stopped using it. I remembered after my first use. I looked like a raccoon and I didn’t even touch my ey

Unfortunately it also smudged on me!

Sameee, super smudgy. Their waterproof one is good though. Doesn't make my lashes look as nice as the regular one though 😭

I love a tubing mascara! It’s the only kind I’ll wear and I’m not opposed to spend money on one I like but I’ve tried Glossier (meh, flakes on me) Merit (not bad but also flakes by the end of the day), Caliray (hated this one! Clumps, smudges, gets all over my lids) and a few others, and recently pi