Come Hell Or Highwater Zero Smudge Clean Mascara

I came to say Caliray as well. It does everything, and you can build it up to be a bit more dramatic (just do it all at once, one eye at a time) but it also looks great if you don't. I put a mini in my mom's stocking one Xmas and converted her instantly.

I have this problem too. I switched to tubing mascara and it was a game changer. Caliray is my personal favorite, because I need volume, and you can layer it nicely (I’ve found that a lot of tubing mascaras get weird when you try to layer them).

I like the caliray mascara, it is tubing but can build a little more volume than other tubing mascaras I’ve tried. You can try a mini to test it out. Mine tend to dry out so I only buy the minis.