Roller Lash

Curl your lashes and add mascara! It would do so much! If you want it to look natural and If your lashes don’t hold a curl, I recommend glossier or benefit roller lash.

I love Roller Lash and wore it for years, but I'm diehard Benefit FanFest user now. I originally got one for free from Adore and have repurchased twice! It gives me the fluttery, defined lashes of my dreams

About face 1994 mascara is great for adding length, but can be quite heavy (formula is more on the wet side), so if you don't have a natural curl you might not like it. Benefit roller lash has a good balance of curl and length but dries out quickly which gives a more natural look imo, but not everyo

Lancôme Hypnodrama when I’m feeling the need for volume Benefit Roller lash for a more subtle everyday

Try benefits roller lash. Its the only one I can wear with contacts that looks good too.

Omg. I changed loyalty from years of loving Roller Lash from Benefit to this tubing mascara because I was starting to get smudging under my eyes similar to OP (change in body chemistry?) It is a magnificent mascara—no smudging and the finished look is quite nice. It doesn’t budge until I take it off

It’s ok but not waterproof. I say it’s for that “natural” lash. One I prefer is the Haus Labs mascara. If I’m going “natural” I prefer the Tower28 or Benefit Roller Lash. The Mario felt underwhelming.

I love Benefit Roller Lash for super long and dramatic and Mabelline Great Lash for more everyday.

Thanks for this! I don’t mind tubing mascaras or not, I use jojoba oil to take makeup off because I just like knowing it’s really gone. It melts through waterproof mascara easily (although I never use waterproof formulas daily). I’ve even heard sky high be referred to as a tubing formula, but I thin

Benefit Roller Lash. Hands down best mascara for my eyes. Doesn't smudge throughout the day, doesnt irritate my eyes, does look great.